Tiberio`s Pizza in Lancaster

Tiberio`s Pizza in Lancaster
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

2610 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 43130-8216, Lancaster

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do you have Sunday hours?

I think it's from noon till 8pm

Is it carry out only?

They do dine-in, carry out, and delivery.

do you deliver?

Yes

Does the Schorr Family still own and operate Tibereo's on Columbus St. By Shell?

? But the food tastes the exact same as before! Yummy!

Why are they not answering the phone at 7pm Sunday night. I just came back from Georgia.:(

They are closed today and tomorrow for Labor Day

Do they deliver? If yes, do they deliver to the Tiki lane area?

Yes , the owners are very nice and yes i believe thats an area that they cover

Why aren't you answering, I'm calling to place an order

Same

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Tiberio`s Pizza
SM
Shane Moneymaker
google
11.06.2024
5/5

Bangin food for real.

Tiberio`s Pizza
MM
Michelle McCrady
google
10.03.2018
5/5

Love the meatball sub! Only meatballs I'll buy.

Tiberio`s Pizza
EH
Eric Herron
google
10.01.2018
5/5

Food is amazing. Especially the stromboli.

Tiberio`s Pizza
IA
Ian Angel
google
09.03.2018
5/5

Who would have thought a pizza place shared with a gas station would make such great pizza. Me.

Tiberio`s Pizza
Ps
Paige s
google
09.01.2018
5/5

Their stromboli is to die for!! Jerry makes the best!! Salads, burgers, pizza is delicious choices as well!

Tiberio`s Pizza
JB
Jeffery Bush
google
08.20.2018
4/5

Great place for dinner

Tiberio`s Pizza
JH
Jeanette Hayes
google
08.09.2018
5/5

Have said it before, but if you have tried a Tiberios stromboli, you are missing out!! Our family orders it without mushrooms, but I'm sure even with it's just as delicious when you pair it with their amazing marinara sauce. 11 out of 10!!

Tiberio`s Pizza
LM
Laurie M Auxier
google
08.09.2018
5/5

The strombolli I got was so delish and my husbands philly steak sub was scrumptous

Tiberio`s Pizza
DM
Doug Mccafferty
google
08.06.2018
5/5

The best stromboli you will put in your mouth hole. Period. You walk in and you're family. If you catch it on a day where they have their potato soup, consider yourself lucky and order up a bowl! You can't go wrong with this place despite being connected to a gas station. Don't let that fool you! Lancaster's best hidden gem!

Tiberio`s Pizza
GS
Greg Spears
google
08.03.2018
5/5

Everyone is very nice Service is great fast and the food is great

Tiberio`s Pizza
ac
amanda cogdill
google
07.23.2018
5/5

Great authentic Italian food, good prices, nice staff.

Tiberio`s Pizza
WZ
Wally Ziolo
google
07.12.2018
5/5

Always a tasty offering... Personal pizza and side salad with Luciana's Dressing is a perfect lunch!

Tiberio`s Pizza
BG
Bill Grine
google
06.16.2018
5/5

The best Stromboli in town

Tiberio`s Pizza
TG
Terri Grine
google
05.18.2018
5/5

It is the best place to eat in Lancaster! And I'm serious.

Tiberio`s Pizza
tb
tessa bigerton
google
05.11.2018
5/5

I’ve been going to Tiberios since I was a little kid when they were on Main Street. Their pizza was heaven on crust, and that stands true today. The people are helpful and just as sweet as their sauce. I’m glad they’ve been able to stay open for so long and I wish them a million more successful years. Thank you

Tiberio`s Pizza
CK
Chuck Keese
google
04.24.2018
5/5

Just as clean efficient and tasty as it was so many years ago located downtown on aMain Steet

Tiberio`s Pizza
MA
Mark Auxier
google
03.24.2018
5/5

Real Italian food really good

Tiberio`s Pizza
LB
Lori Bourne
google
02.26.2018
4/5

The food is delicious, its always a family treat when I order on Friday nights for dinner. The worker who answers the phone for call in orders, (seems like I always get the same lady) is rude. She put me on hold twice, both times when coming back to the phone forgot I had already started ordering, and had to start all over. At the end of ordering I said thank you, no response to that, no goodbye. just hangs up. You are speaking to your customers, I understand being busy, I work in customer service as well. You are in business because of your customers, show a little bit of kindness, goes a long way with customers.

Tiberio`s Pizza
MJ
Mary Jo Cline
google
01.03.2018
3/5

Very good stromboli, friendly fast service, highly recommend

Tiberio`s Pizza
KD
Kenny Dillon
google
11.17.2017
5/5

Awesome food and customer service

Tiberio`s Pizza
KS
Kim Spaulding-Buescher
google
11.08.2017
4/5

As read before going in..... the stromboli IS excellent!! The bread is deliciously sweet and crunchy, the cheese is plentiful- the only complaint I have is that the meat was not evenly distributed, the pepperoni was mostly piled on just one side not leaving room for any other ingredients in the bite- otherwise juicy and good flavor. Got a deluxe cheeseburger- was tasty tho nothing special for almost $4 and no fries- I easily could have duplicated it at home. I look forward to trying their pizza on my next visit along with a stromboli of course!

Tiberio`s Pizza
LV
Luis Valverde
google
11.05.2017
5/5

Always on point with food and really good service

Tiberio`s Pizza
AC
Anthony Christy
google
09.17.2017
5/5

You just can't go wrong. Pizza, subs, all great. Lunch specials, delicious. Great friendly service. We make sure to swing by every time we are in Lancaster.

Tiberio`s Pizza
RS
Ric Schorr
google
09.15.2017
5/5

BY FAR the BEST REAL Italian menu at least in the central Ohio area. Family owned business where the owner was born & raised in Italy bringing her family recipes with her. Truly a Lancaster hidden secret that like ALL small family businesses in our community needs the support of the community. I guarantee you that you and your guests will not be disappointed if you order a "REAL" homemade stromboli or leave still hungry!

Tiberio`s Pizza
BW
Bonnie Wright
google
08.24.2017
5/5

Best fish sandwiches in town. Chef salad very good too. They were extremely busy. We ordered our for takeout.

Tiberio`s Pizza
DC
Debbie Cook-Landrum
google
06.27.2017
2/5

Always had the best Stromboli. However, the last 2 we have ordered were over cooked, leaving the bottom crust hard and unable to chew. The location is not conveniently located. Parking lot has a lot of pot holes that could damage your vehicle if your not careful. There is usually no where to park either. Not impressed at all anymore 😑

Tiberio`s Pizza
SH
Stephanie Howell
google
06.18.2017
5/5

We love getting pizza from here. The cheese pizza is the best. One issues is hours and they can get busy. So calling multiple times is a must on the weekends.we also love the lady who is usually at the front taking orders. Make sure to order the xl pizza and pick up is a good option.

Tiberio`s Pizza
TD
Ted Davis
google
06.16.2017
5/5

It is value added. I saw part of the original downtown crew still making it fresh. The recipes are right off the boat. Everything is great. My kids love this place. We had the Stromboli. It was so worth it.

Tiberio`s Pizza
TB
Terry Bird
google
05.27.2017
5/5

We have never left Tiberios disappointed. Their pizza and Stromboli are off the chains. Don’t let the fact that they are in a gas station building fool you, you’ll be hard pressed to find better pizza anywhere in central Ohio.

Tiberio`s Pizza
RW
Russell Wilson
google
04.19.2017
4/5

Great food, prices, people & atmosphere!

Tiberio`s Pizza
BH
Becky Hartley
google
04.15.2017
5/5

Great food. Friendly service

Tiberio`s Pizza
BO
Barbra ORourke
google
03.04.2017
5/5

Fabulous pizza, all fresh n homemade

Tiberio`s Pizza
ic
iced cold
google
11.15.2016
5/5

Great people amazing food

Tiberio`s Pizza
JH
Jan Hall
google
11.12.2016
5/5

This place in the greatest. Their stromboi are the best ever. So much meat and cheese. The best i have ever had.

Tiberio`s Pizza
LS
L S
google
11.07.2016
5/5

This is a Lancaster Legend!! The pizzaria has had a few different locations over the years but the quality has never deviated. We love the stromboli from here! It's all hand made fresh packed with meat and cheese. The sauce is sweet, they give you plenty of it. So if you're like me who likes a lot of sauce for the stromboli you'll be satisfied. I recommend there side salad with the in house Italian. Its creamy and delicious. This is by far the best pizzeria in town. Go get a slice or a stromboli you wont be sorry!

Tiberio`s Pizza
RS
Rodney Sellers
google
10.11.2016
5/5

First-time experience food was awesome we will be back for more

Tiberio`s Pizza
BL
Bradley Lutz
google
10.08.2016
5/5

One of the best strombolis I have ever had. Period. Perfectly cooked every time. Great tasting bread. Sweet sauce. Chock full of pepperoni, ham, mushrooms and cheese. It is well worth a visit even if you are just traveling through. Honestly, it is so good that I have never tried anything else there!

Tiberio`s Pizza
MB
Mari Byers
google
10.08.2016
5/5

Always delicious! Good sized prtions. Love it!

Tiberio`s Pizza
KC
Kristina Courtney
google
10.02.2016
5/5

Great pizza! Always friendly and polite staff. Decent pricing. A little out of the way, but worth it! Definitely my favorite "Mom and Pop" pizza joint

Tiberio`s Pizza
LT
LEANDRE Tankersley
google
09.26.2016
5/5

Wonderful food.

Tiberio`s Pizza
MJ
Melissa Julian
google
07.15.2016
5/5

The stromboli is awesome.. huge serving love the sauce..."Moms". Sweet dipping sauce.. you can tell it's home made😘

Tiberio`s Pizza
PR
Pamela Reygaert
google
07.11.2016
5/5

Great! The Stromboli is awesome. We've tried the spaghetti and the lasagna and loved them too

Tiberio`s Pizza
JV
Jackeline Velazquez
google
07.01.2016
5/5

Love this pizza, and the bread

Tiberio`s Pizza
CR
C R
google
06.09.2016
5/5

Great tasting pizza and salads. I love the homemade dressing, and the pizza sauce and crust. Nice crispy crust and nice sweet sauce. Some places have a strong bitter or salty sauce, but not here. That's what attracted me and keeps me coming back for more. A great place to stop for a meal. It is probably my go to place when I'm in Lancaster and wanting pizza. Recommended!

Tiberio`s Pizza
om
odog moon
google
04.27.2016
5/5

Great food! Great staff!

Tiberio`s Pizza
SS
Steve Starr
google
04.16.2016
4/5

We shared a salad with their homemade Italian dressing, truly outstanding. Next was the pizza, a treat for the tastebuds. Everything, from the crust to the sauce, it was a delightful meal.

Tiberio`s Pizza
TC
Tyler Coy
google
04.01.2016
2/5

The food is good, but that's it. They regularly close early. That's lazy and shows a terrible work ethic. They are constantly understaffed as well. They make it very difficult to order.

Tiberio`s Pizza
SU
Steven Uhl
google
03.19.2016
4/5

Great pizza and subs, but parking can get tight.

Tiberio`s Pizza
CJ
Colleen Justus
google
03.03.2016
5/5

Really the best there is!!!! This food is aspecial treat for anyone. Tastes great EVERY time! Wish they were back downtown again.

Tiberio`s Pizza
GV
Gary Viken
google
01.23.2016
5/5

Great personal service. Food was great. We had pizza, crust and sauce are the best.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17406542317

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!